ELIE’S SIN –BACKGROUND NOTES
Numbered footnotes and additional notes written April 29, 2002
ELIE’S SIN is a mixed media artwork on paper 1984-87 by Akiva Kenneth
Segan
(formerly Kenneth Akiva Segan)
The original notes as were typed ca. 1988-89
Analysis of the work ELIE’S SIN:
1) The image to the (viewers) right of Wiesel’s head is a
SALUTING
CONCENTRATION CAMP GUARD TOWER.
(I walked up the guard tower which adjoins the train entryway to
Birkenau (1)
where (the Nazi officer and medical doctor known as "The Angel of
Death") Josef Mengele made his selections (2)
giving me an overview of the size and scale of the camp (3).
2) COURT CASE – CONTACT INTERPOL (4)
DEPT
HEAD refers to Interpol's purported collaboration
with the Nazi’s.
3) 800 INFO ASSIST
is an oblique reference to the American apathy (concerning the
extermination of European Jewry)
Further wordage:
4) DESCRIP(tion) INMATE W(iesel
born) 1928
use CAUTION - EXTRANJ(ero, Spanish for
foreigner)
6) SPE(aks),
REA(ds) WRI(tes)
FRENCH OTHERS (5)
7) ARM-ed BOOK THIEF
(refers to the Germans theft of Jewish everything, in particular for
their infamous Jewish Historical Museum collections) (6)
8) YID aka KIKE
with the hat and umbrella in a parody image of alight-bulb lit show
marquee and/or someone dancing…my goal was and is to have viewers
think about what these pejorative (7)
words mean and their common use in society
JEW ALERT! may mean an alert for Jews (danger,
Nazi’s) by Jews or an alert for Jews
by the Nazi enemy
The swastika is done in a manner that I haven’t seen in post-war
work about the
Holocaust (which isn’t to say it hasn’t been done but that I’m
unaware of anything comparable). My intention is to get the viewer to
think about the symbol and its meaning.
11) ELIE’S SIN
of course refers to the "SIN" of having been born Jewish and,
hence, marked for death…RESISTED
DEATH of course places Wiesel, and any other
of the fraction of Jewish survivors (8),
in that group who bear witness (9)
12) The text at the bottom:
This was, is and will be, G-d willing, a Jest (or test) of the
Viewer’s Visual Broadcast System, as given in the G-D given creative
abilities I have been blessed with. I wish to thank my parents, my
brother, my companion and privy counsellor of the last two years, H.J.D.
of Tacoma and Seattle, and lastly, to pay homage to my grandparents,
Little and Jacob S., and Sarah and Harry, who came to America from
Kiev (8), Vilnius (9), Bialystok (10), and Odessa (11). And I must raise
another ? for which I thank Mr. Wiesel:: Are we, Jews and non-Jews
alike, all survivors of the Holocaust? Proscribed before myself, I am,
Kenneth Akiva Segan
Religious witness Rabbi James Mirel
Framed witness Edwin R. Wirkala
Storeroom witness Heidi J. Drucker
(all witnessed in January 1987)
I added the following note around 1992:
"The railroad spikes in the frame were added in 1991, the symbolism
of course concerning the trains which crisscrossed war-ravaged Europe
(and an increasingly beaten German army) taking Jews to their deaths
till the end of the war."
Footnotes and additional notes - April 29, 2002:
(1) The
larger of the two sites that made up the Auschwitz-Birkenau death and
concentration camp complex. According to the ‘Encyclopedia of the
Third Reich’ by Louis Snyder (McGraw Hill, 1976) "it is estimated
from one to four million persons died in gas ovens and in a variety of
other methods at Auschwitz."
(2) Selections at Auschwitz-Birkenau were to the
"Right!" (slave labor) or "Left!" (to be murdered in
the gas chambers)
(3) It was huge,
the size of a whole city. I saw the remains of barracks – chimneys
near and far-off in the distance in front of me.
(4) The
International Criminal Police Organization is the organization used by
police departments worldwide requesting assistance across national
borders.
(5) Referring to (Elie) Wiesel. To the best of my
knowledge Wiesel speaks and understands Yiddish, Hebrew, French,
English, and. perhaps languages also. Wiesel was born in Sighet,
Romania, Sept. 30, 1928. He and his family were deported to
concentration and death camps. The story of his
father’s death by his side formed an integral part of his first book
"Night," in the 1950’s. World-renowned as the leading
spokesperson on the Shoah and the author of numerous fiction and
non-fiction books, he won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1986.
(6) I was
probably referring to the immense collections – warehouses full of
objects (ritual religious objects, pianos, Torahs, etc) stolen from
Czech Jews by the Nazi’s, catalogued and collected to house their
planned "research" and propaganda institute and museum about
Jewry in Prague, a sort of post-war anthropology museum. Most of the
Jews involved in the cataloguing were murdered. The 1983 Smithsonian
Institution book "The Precious Legacy – Judaic Treasures from the
Czechoslovak State Collections," edited by David Altshuler,
chronicles this history in text and with photos.
(7) disparaging or derogatory
(8) Three-fourths of European Jews were murdered.
Had the war in Europe lasted another six months,
millions more would have been murdered.
(9) Wiesel and
other survivors speak of "Bearing Witness" to the genocide
THE DRAWING – HOW IT BEGAN:
The portrait of Wiesel was the first thing
drawn in the work. Media: Pencil, colored pencil, charcoal and white
ink.
This was done between the summers of 1984 and 1985 between my first and
second trips to Poland. The photo used as inspiration for the portrait
was by William Coupon and appeared on the cover of the New York Times
Sunday Magazine, October 23, 1983.
The cover story was titled "BEARING WITNESS: THE LIFE AND WORK OF
ELIE WIESEL"by Samuel G. Freedman.
The artwork was shelved for at least a year afterwards as I was in
Europe and the U.K. from June to December 1985.
In 1986, back in Seattle, I drew the rest of the imagery: the
checkerboard pattern (to viewers right of Wiesel’s head), the partial
and complete words, the color swastika, the guard tower, etc.
THE RUBBER STAMPS AND POSTAGE STAMPS: The rubber stamps and postage
stamps were probably added last, but before the Witnesses signed their
names. The order of the rubber stamps below the guard tower read left to
right
FRAMED - SIN - OFFICIALLY NOTED.
The rubber stamps used to make SIN and ANULOWANO were stamped from a
rubber stamp set of individual letters. The Star of David rubber stamp
was from my own rubber stamp collection.
The "EXPIRED," "DOES NOT CIRCULATE,"
RELIGIOUS," SIGNATURE," "CANCELLED,"
"EXAMPLES," "Framed," "HISTORICAL," ‘DISCARD,"
"Use no thumb tacks gummed tape or mark in any way," "DO
NOT FOLD" and "OFFICIALLY NOTED" rubber stamps were used
courtesy of the old Art & Music Dept. at Seattle Public Library,
where I worked part-time as a clerk 1982-85.
THE FORTUNE COOKIE:
The fortune cookie fortune at lower right states "He who suffers
remembers." It came in a fortune cookie I got (twice) at Kau-Kau
Restaurant on King Street in Seattle’s International District. The
fortune seemed particularly Jewish to me at the time. It still does.
The POSTAGE STAMPS are French.
The YID, KIKE and JEW ALERT! wordage and visuals are high satire and
black humor at my finest. It doesn’t get any better!
OF "ELIE’S SIN" AND CHILDREN:
After the work was purchased by University Congregational Church in
Seattle, several adult board members claimed would be
inappropriate for children and would disturb them.
My response is that children will have no problem viewing this artwork
at all, although I’d write age-appropriate information signage about
its meaning and symbolic imagery.
That some adults will have a problem on seeing this artwork is already
self-evident. A college friend, raised Roman Catholic in Chicago, told
me on hearing of this, that "If parents want to have a fright about
paintings and sculptures that might cause fear and terror in their
children, they should take their kids to see crucifixion artworks of Jesus."
OF ELIE'S SIN AND RESPONSES OF CHRISTIAN VIEWERS, I think of these words
which I read in the book "HARRY JAMES CARGAS in conversation with
ELIE WIESEL" (Paulist Press, 1976):"The
sincere Christian knows that what died at Auschwitz was not the Jewish
people but Christianity."
The quote is from Cargas, who was a Catholic teacher. |